—————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
Become Fan of Karka Nirka Blog in Facebook
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Karka-Nirka/353094691592
————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
This blog has been edited after a reader Mr.Ashraf pointed out a mistake in previous version. You can see his comment in the comment section. Thank you Mr. Ashraf.
————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
Found another beautiful poem. Sangam literature is serving purpose of teaching me botany. By the time I finish reading Sangam literature I hope I can identify most of the plants and trees in Tamil Nadu. If you wondered why I am saying this , the poem below would give a perfect explanation.
Thalaivan has met Thalaivi and the are in love. Thalaivan is from the neighboring village. The love affair between Thalaivan and Thalaivi is a gossip in the town and the parents of Thalaivi come to know about it. Thalaivi is under strict supervision of her parents. Only time she can meet Thalaivan is in the midnight when her parents are asleep. Thalaivan comes through the forest in the dark and hides near the house of Thalaivi and makes some signals – mostly some kind of sound. Thalaivi understanding such signal would sneak out of the house and meet her lover. They would spend the whole night together.
In one such occasion , Thalaivan comes and hides and the Thalaivi didn’t get the signal and they couldn’t meet in the night. So next day when she and her friend(Panki- always accompanies her and more of companion) see Thalaivan , Panki talks very loudly to Thalaivi so that Thalaivan can hear it and utters the poem below.
Kurunthokai 138
138. குறிஞ்சி
கொன் ஊர் துஞ்சினும், யாம் துஞ்சலமே-
எம் இல் அயலது ஏழில் உம்பர்,
மயில் அடி இலைய மாக் குரல் நொச்சி
அணி மிகு மென் கொம்பு ஊழ்த்த
மணி மருள் பூவின் பாடு நனி கேட்டே.
குறி பிழைத்த தலைமகன் பிற்றை ஞான்று இரவுக்குறி வந்துழி, தோழி சிறைப்புறமாகக் கூறியது; இரவுக்குறி நேர்ந்ததூஉம் ஆம். – கொல்லன் அழிசி
பரந்து விரிந்த்ருகும் இவ்வூர் தூங்கியது,
எங்கள் வீட்டின் அருகில் உள்ள ,
எழில் என்ற பெயர் கொண்ட மலையில்,
மயிலினது அடியைப் போல் இலைகளை கொண்ட
நொச்சி மரத்தின் மென்மையானக் கொம்புகளில்
அணி அணியாக தொங்கும் பெரிய பூங்கொத்துகள்,
உதிர்ந்து மணி போன்ற பூக்கள் விழும்
ஓசையை கேட்டுக்கொண்டே ,
நாங்கள் தூங்காமல் விழித்திருந்தோம் !
The vast city had slept, we did not.
We heard the sound
of clourful clusters of aged flowers
which look like sapphires,
decorated on the soft branches of
the nochhi tree, with leaves like peacock feet,
falling down
on the Ezhil mountains closer to our house.
Poet:Kollan Azhici
Translated by Palaniappan Vairam
By uttering this poem the Panki says that they were very attentive to the extent they could hear flowers falling but they couldn’t hear any signal from Thalaivan. So if some is to be blamed for Thalaivan and Thalaivi not meeting previous day it must be the Thalaivan for not giving proper signal. She says this to make it clear that Thalaivi did not avoid Thalaivan , rather she was waiting to meet Thalaivan the previous night.
Ezhil here is the mountain in Kingdom of King Nannan.
Now it would be interesting to learn about the Nocchi tree.
, n. 1. Five-leaved chaste tree. See வெண்ணொச்சி. நொச்சி மாமலர் நிறத்தன (சீவக. 2163). 2. Three-leaved chaste tree. See கருநொச்சி. 3. (Puṟap.) See நொச்சித்திணை. நொச்சிப்படலம். (பு. வெ. 5.) 4. (Puṟap.) A minor theme eulogising the nocci
But we should also look at this word
மயிலடி¹ mayil-aṭti
3. Tall chaste-tree. See காட்டுநொச்சி,
காட்டுநொச்சி kāṭṭttu-nocci
, n. < id. +. (L.) 1. Tall chaste tree, l. tr., Vitex altissima; நொச்சி மரவகை.
We see so many different varieties of Nocchi. But there is clue in poem “leaves like peacock feet” so with this clue I search for the tree.
To understand the leaves we first need to know how a peacock feet would look like.
So it looks like the plant is going to have three leaves together like the peacock feet.
Lets see the leaves of this kaatu nochi
So lets have closer look at peacock feet once again.
Peacock foot has 4 fingers and one at the back.
See the foot print of a peacock below.
Lets check out the leaves once again now in comparison with peacock foot print.
Now you would understand why the leaves look like the peacock feet.
Now Lets see the flower
Compare this with a Sapphire stone.
More about the flower : http://www.biotik.org/india/species/v/vitealti/vitealti_en.html
http://www.flowersofindia.net/catalog/slides/Peacock%20Chaste%20Tree.html
The poet compares the blue shades of the flower and the Sapphire stone as well as says the tree’s leaves are like peacock’s feet. The Sangam poets have always described nature as integral part of love poems to add to the emotions of the poem.
We also come to know that Noocchi flowers fall in the night!
Now you would understand that learning Sangam poem also gives you a big lesson in Botany!
After seeing this tree you should understand the underlying sarcasm of Panki. She mocks at the Thalaivan saying we could hear even leaves from the tree falling but not your signal!
———————————————————————————————————
Other Available translations:
What Her Friend Said:
Even though the whole
large town sleeps,
we do not sleep,
hearing distinctly the sound
of blue flowers
shaken off the beautiful , soft branches
of the nocci tree,with leaves
like peacock’s feet,
and dark flower bunches on Ezhil hill,
near my home.
Translated by Shanmugam Pillai and David Ludden
The great city fall asleep
but we did not sleep.
Clearly we heard,all night,
from the hillock next out house
the tender branches of the flower-clustered tree
with leaves like peacock-feet
let fall
their blue-sapphire flowers.
Translated by A.K.Ramanujan
Word by Word Translation:
கொன் ஊர் துஞ்சினும், யாம் துஞ்சலமே-
Vast – town – sleep- we- no sleep
எம் இல் அயலது ஏழில் உம்பர்,
our – house -near – Ezhil(mountain name)- mountain
மயில் அடி இலைய மாக் குரல் நொச்சி
peacock- feet- leaves – colourful- flower cluster- Nocchi
அணி மிகு மென் கொம்பு ஊழ்த்த
decoration- more – soft- branch- mature/aged
மணி மருள் பூவின் பாடு நனி கேட்டே.
sapphire- like – flower- sound – abundant – hear.
———————————————————————————————————
Palaniappan Vairam Sarathy
———————————————————————————————————
Reference:
Fifteen poems from a classical Tamil anthology by A.K.Ramanujan.
Kurunthokai Translation by Shanmugam Pillai and David Ludden.
Kurunthokai Urai by U.V.Swaminathan Iyer.
Tamil Lexicon
———————————————————————————————————
கற்க... நிற்க ... 
superb….hope thaliavan gets the message. They should think of better signal !!
lovely vairam
rgds
vj
Although I like your posts, I need to make a suggestion here. The Nochi plant found in India is Vitex Negundo and not Vitex trifolia. The former is prevalent in India and especially South India and the latter is found in East Africa.
Having said that, the flowers are blue in color but not as bright as Vitex trifolia and the leaves are more sharp than trifolia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitex_negundo
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitex_trifolia
Amazing vairam.. looking forward for more like this.. all the best..
karu nochchi rarer than the other one and has medicinal properties.
Hi Ragothaman,
I would like to point out that Vitex Trifolia is also found in Tamil Nadu and is known as Karu nocchi. By the description given by the poet – its more like 3 leaf tree than a 5 leaf one.
http://www.flowersofindia.net/catalog/slides/Three-Leaved%20Chaste%20Tree.html
I have done enough verification before putting up this post.
Vairam
Hi Vairam, I agree with you on that and also on the point that you do extensive research before posting. However, the poem you have posted doesn’t say if the poet referred to Karu Nocchi or Nir Nocchi. It plainly refers to Nocchi. To my bot…any trained eyes, I can see resemblance of peacock’s legs to Vitex Negundo rather than Vitex trifolia. 1. The Peacock’s leg shown in color photo shows how the four toes are spread out like leaves of Vitex negundo and not like the three-leaved Vitex trifolia.
2. The leaf spread of Vitex negundo is close to the thin toes of peacock than the wider leaf of Vitex trifolia.
In the same website when I searched for just “nocchi”, I get this result: http://www.flowersofindia.net/catalog/slides/Chaste%20Tree.html
Hi!! Very nice… Amazing to see the poet making beautiful comparisons… and you are doing a real great job by letting us also understand and enjoy the beauty of the sangam poems. Thanks a lot..
Regards
Vardhini
That’s a great undertaking, identifying all plants of TN! I hope you’ll have Tamil name,Hindi name, Botanical Name & English name w photo of ea., preferably in flower. Bark photo is useful, of course, too for trees.
There is another website beginning to do this but can’t find the reference quickly, you might google it.
Hi Vairam,
Thanks for an updated post on this. I still do not completely agree if Vitex trifolia is the one the poet talks about. Since Vitex negundo also has a variety with blue flowers. In any case…Let us agree to disagree on this.
🙂
Keep posting more interesting stuff that tickles our gray matters…
Vairam ,
This post was one of the few i have read in your blog and have found something common with the other poems i read here. To clarify, I cannot read tamizh and so had to read the english translations. In each of the translations i read, even after reading the context of the poem, I could not make any sense at all of what the poet was trying to say. It was all a big mess of randomness. An animal pops out here, a tree pops out there and interspersed with flowers and spices and herbs and what not.
And then after i read your annotations and explanations, saw your pictures and comparisons, it all made sense to me. Very cleverly done by the Poet.
And so this brings up a question.
Why is sangam poetry so complex? The first step to appreciating a work of art is understanding the emotions it evokes in the hearts of the viewer. In a form like sangam poetry, which relies so much on similies and metaphors, would not the beauty be more apparent if it is a little more straight forward? Is it because I am dumb to poetry and the people of those days were smart enough to interpret the poet’s views immediately without someone like you to explain it to them with pictures?
If you say that the beauty of the poetry was in the complexity of the comparisons, do you think that the poems were to be looked upon as puzzles to be solved, the king would conduct a competition for the most complex poem and give away prizes to the interpreter like in Thiruvilayadal Movie?
Hari,
The problem lies in the translation and not in the poetry. Tamil is a language with no punctuations. It is a free flowing language with no starts and ends. So its a big problem when you translate. Translation doesn’t give you the whole sense. The word play the musical quality and structure are lost in translation.
If you can understand the language and read the original text you will enjoy it much more. As regards to any art you need to know the background to appreciate any art. Most people dont know whats special about Modern or Abstract art. Unless some one explains or you are accustomed to art , you cant appreciate most arts. Same goes here with poetry. There are certain structures , certain literary norms and some formulas to be followed to write this poem. It just deals with just 5 topics. So with so many restriction the poet just give so much new emotion in every poem.
Tamil Padam- the spoof… wont be interesting if you dont understand the back stories!
Thanks for the 1000th comment!
Vairam
Vairam,
“A Job well done” is not just a word to appreciate the work that you are doing here.. This effort makes the sangam poem looks easy as it is not in original. This is really really encouraging and a very good research of a time well spent… Good and keep going… 🙂
Vaalthu gal. A very nice and novel attempt.Very Interesting.Please continue this
Vairam, another gem of a post, thank you.
As far as translations go, it is very difficult to appreciate translated poems (tamil has its specialities) but even then poetry can only be enjoyed fully in its own native, unless there is a huge amount of effort put into translation, as some american translators have done with Rumi and Hafiz. Maybe you will introduce sangam poetry to the western world as they have done 🙂
Better late than never, they say. Glad to join this group, discussing about the beauty of Sangam literature. T
The comparison of the palmlately compound leaf with the feet of the peacock is amazing to say the least. Being a wildlifer, I appreciate the discussions here. Would like to contribute my own way as well in future.
What about Vitex altissima, another species found in the Western Ghats? It is not uncommon in evergreen and semi-evergreen landscapes. In fact this species is called Peacock Chaste Tree….!!! Tamil name given in the link below is மயிலாடி or மயிலை நொச்சி.
http://www.flowersofindia.net/catalog/slides/Peacock%20Chaste%20Tree.html
Thank you very much Mr. Ashraf, collecting details on this variety and one more variety of Peacock chaste. Will update it by tonight and credit you in the post.
Thank you very much for this input.
GUSHING WITH WORDS WHICH MAKES ME TO STRUGLE TO APPRECIATE THE GREAT WORK YOU ARE DOING MR VAIRAM.FOR ME THERE IS NO WORD TO EXPRESS.I LOVE TO READ PURANANURU TRANSLATED POEM IN SCHOOL DAYS.LATER I WAS SEARCHING FOR THE SAME FOR ENTIRE POEMS.FORTUNATELY I FOUND YOU.THE IMAGINATION OF THE POET IS BROUGHT LIVE BY YOU.PERHAPS YOU MAY BE THE POET IN THE PERIVIUOS JANNAMA.LET YOUR SERVICE TO BE CONTINUED.
THANK YOU
NATHAN
Vairam,
Couple of months back I purchased a book “தமிழரும் தாவரமும்” by K.V. Krishnamoorthy (a 2007 publication of Bharatidasan University). It is a comprehensive work, taking us through the ages of Tamil civilization. From pages 322 to 328, he provides the names of 207 plants mentioned in Sangam literature. I am sure the list would include these 99 as well. However, he has not provided the botanical names these plants, in spite of he being a botanist of the university.
This work might be of use to you.
Thank you Mr. Ashraf, I would get the book when ever I go to India.
Regards
vairam
Mr. Vairam,
Nice work and keep up your great contribution.
impressed by this great work.. keep it up..
Hi,
I wanted to share something….
உம்பர் – uyarntha
மா – karumai enra porulum undu….
குரல் – koththu(tamil aharathiyil eduthathu)
மருள் – கள் (tamil aharathiyil eduthathu)
So, “mayiladu kaal pondra ilaikalai udaya uyarntha nochi marathin azhahana menmayana kilayil vilangum kariya nochippoongoththu uthirkum mani pol minnum kal pol chuvaikkum pookkalin oasaiyai ketta vannam ipperoore urangungal naam urangadirunthom…… ” ipdi solla varar nu ninaikren…..
அற்புதமான கட்டுரை. அவசியம், இத்தகைய தொகுப்பை, ஒரு புத்தகமாக வெளியிடுங்கள். சங்கப் பாடல்களைப் அனுபவிப்பதில் உள்ள பெரும்தடையை உங்கள் கட்டுரைகள் நீக்கும்.
அன்புடன்,
கரிகாலன்
great job sir .I would like thanks you. Nocchi kulam is the village name still now used I think thirunelveli or thoothukudi dist. I have seen these leaf in the dist.
dear Sundar, I am a late entrant to this blog.There is a free software NHRM website .it helps you to get Tamil words typed from Roman English,phonetically.
The discussion about Nochi identification is rather pointless for the poetry enjoyment.what is important is that the tree(whatever be the botonical name!) sheds the flowers and the feeble noise keeps the girl awake.Enjoy the poem and forget research!
regarding the comment,of Hariharan Narayanan, why Tamil poetry of Sangam period is difficult today for us(who are lazy to learn it well) is that Tamil has changed over centuries in script,language,and usage in spoken and written forms.Hence the difficulty.Imagine the effort of U.V..Swaminatha Iyer,Raghava Iyengar, Mr Pope.Mr.Hart and of course Vairam and NVK Ashraf(Sir,I presume you are a muslim with remarkable insight,knowledge and love for தமிழ்) ,in making these intelligible to us. They should be revered and appreciated. bala
Dear tkb1936rlys,
more kavithanubhavam comes when we try to research and attribute meanings in different perspectives in our way. If the poet wanted to keep it that simple, he would have had the poem in two lines. Might be the poet wanted to tell more things from the detailed description.
Dear sir
it’s my first visit to this site, i found what i search for a long time. We have a treasure (our literature) alas we lost of vision. let your work lighten all
regards
Mahesh
அருமையான பதிவு. இயற்கையும் செய்யுளும் எப்படி ஒத்துப் போகின்றன என்று எடுத்துக் காட்டியது மிக ருசிகரமாக இருந்தது.